Lanka Newspapers

Sri Lanka News Updates with Discussions

Lanka Newspaperssansare's Home PageThis Page




Image media

Thursday, 14 May 2009 - 7:06 PM SL Time

Image media !

[HRW and AAAS (American Association for the
Advancement of Science) explanation for the image:

This image shows interior walls, likely evidence of burning, of destroyed
permanent structures in the CZ on May 6, 2009 (Lat: 9.31 N Long: 80.77 E).]

First see the AAAS/HRW image at top.

Then, see these yellow marked building locations in goggle image in centre image. All places are empty, and google image is also not very old (may be 2009, digital globe image).

Then see the bottom image, specially location A and B.
When bombs or shells destroyed just next houses, these blue marked houses are intact.

Conclusion:
The HRW red arrow marked buildings may have destroyed, but not 100% sure about the bomb involvement. One possibility is, those buildings have build very recently and also removed when SLA advanced. May be partly damage by fire or purposely destroyed by LTTE to hide some evidence. If we can have more images, this hypothesis is easy to check. Anyway, the interesting point is, red arrowed buildings are all not visible in Google image, and still nearly all old buildings are intact.

By this analysis, I don`t suggest, war is not destroying civilian property. But the fact is, these sort of satellite image analysis must use more data and must cross-check before publish. These information are not easy for general people to comment and they have to accept without much argument. It hurts a lot, if the truth is not correctly tailored.

Source(s)
By SS - using AAAS, HRW, and Google images.

 Post a reply to this

 E-mail this to a friend




Randu097
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 1767
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 12:19:41 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Good work. Thanks.
I think UN/HRW is trying to scare off SLDF and GOSL.
ColomboDude
Senior Member

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 3255
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 12:23:18 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Good analysis.. thanks
Naaca
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1475
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 12:32:37 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Sansare

I think your analysis is sensible. I wonder what those areas with small squares are. They may be houses under constructin than those have been destroyed. As you say you find intact houses and this kind of structures just next to each other and therefore they cannot be destroyed houses but ones that are in the process of building.

Second photo from bottom appears older than the bottom-most one and there you cannot see those 'houses under construction' type structures, instead corresponding areas are occupied by trees.

Probably Velu has started making a city there to house the hostages and Rights Watch is misinterpreting all that without ground truth!
sansare
Senior Member

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 7408
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 12:33:15 GMT  Report for Abuse  
UN/HRW is trying to scare off SLDF and GOSL

Maybe they want to say facts, but seems need more flesh in them....?
alwaysalion
Senior Member

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6258
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 12:34:38 GMT  Report for Abuse  
It is good that we have a few like you who dig and find facts.
Thanks pal!
sansare
Senior Member

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 7408
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 12:39:58 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Naca,..
Yes, under-construction is one possibility.
Need more verifications in that regard.

Always,..
Thanks.
Parasuram
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 985
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 12:54:04 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Everybody knew LTTErs aren't saints, their method is violence, nobody denies that, but

the UN is prepared to take the risk to find out what is happening in the LTTE controlled area.

If the GOSL thinks that they have nothing to hide and not guilty, then why shouldn't the GOSL allow the UN in the NFZ and the detention camps to find out who killing who? and who bombing who?

The UN had access to other conflict zones, why not in Lanka?
What is there to hide in the NFZ and the detention centres?




Edited By - Parasuram - 14 May 2009 12:56:41 GMT
sansare
Senior Member

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 7408
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 13:34:00 GMT  Report for Abuse  
The UN had access to other conflict zones, why not in Lanka?


This simple image analysis is only to show some points of AAAS work.

Anyway, let UN/IC into the LTTE pocket, GOSL may need lot of other factors to be considered (like, how LTTE response, what if LTTE/un-known sector takes them as hostages and demand SLA to move back,..etc.).
The NFZ is a very small area and risk is high.

If UN/IC is moving there, there must be a no-fire duration from LTTE and SLA.
Roshan2007
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 2531
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 14:14:40 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Best thing is let's finish this off.
The more we drag. all the cats and bulls come up with all stories to save Velu's ass.

The Indian elections are over now it is time to wrap it up.
RealKaruna
Senior Member

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 2597
Member Profile
LK Information  14 May 2009 15:04:21 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Sansare,

I agree with most of what you have written, but it appears that you have chosen to ignore a significant part of the AAAS report:

May 10 Imagery Analysis
Analysis of the May 10 imagery sought to provide some evidence of the events of May 9-10, when reports indicated significant use of artillery or other heavy weapons on the IDP population in the CZ (Conflict Zone), as reflected in UN and other statements. The salient feature of the May 10 image, when compared to the May 6 image, is the obvious removal of thousands of likely IDP structures from the central part of the CZ (see red outlines, Figure Five). While some new areas of IDP structures did appear in the same time period (see yellow outlines, Figure Five), their quantity is not enough to compensate for the sheer number of removed IDP structures. What caused the IDP structures to be removed between May 6 and May 10 is uncertain based on the imagery, though it is certainly unlikely that the IDPs would have moved en masse, and so completely without a compelling reason. It is also notable how complete the removal of IDP structures appears, in that some debris and evidence of the structures remains, but overall the area has been swept relatively clean (see Figure Six). This is less indicative of the entire area being razed by shelling, though it could correspond with an emigration from those specific areas by the IDPs due to some outside driver, such as shelling.


RK
Page | 1  |
 Post a reply to this      E-mail this to a friend



(C) 2000-2008 www.lankanewspapers.com - Sri Lankan News & Discussions - Contact Us - RSS Feed - News Archives - src - FAQ