Lanka Newspapers

Sri Lanka News Updates with Discussions

Lanka NewspapersRevy's Home PageThis Page




Bollywood icon Amitabh Bachchan rubbishes Slumdog Millionaire

Thursday, 15 January 2009 - 7:06 AM SL Time

Slumdog Millionaire may have been thrown bouquets by western critics and audiences, but brickbats are flying in its direction in India.

Although the film was a big winner at Sunday`s Golden Globes and is seen as a frontrunner for the Oscars, Amitabh Bachchan, Bollywood`s top actor and perhaps one of the most famous faces in the world, has voiced bitter comments about the movie`s portrayal of India.

Writing on his blog, Bachchan said that `if SM projects India as [a] third-world, dirty, underbelly developing nation and causes pain and disgust among nationalists and patriots, let it be known that a murky underbelly exists and thrives even in the most developed nations.`

There has been some debate about the `Indian-ness` of the movie. Slumdog Millionaire was directed by the British film-maker Danny Boyle, best known for the noir comedy of Trainspotting. The film is based on a novel, Q&A, by the Indian writer and diplomat Vikas Swarup, and adapted by Simon Beaufoy, the British screenwriter of The Full Monty.

Bachchan added that an Indian director making a western-style film might not meet with the attention lavished on Slumdog Millionaire: `It`s just that the SM idea, authored by an Indian and conceived and cinematically put together by a westerner, gets creative globe recognition. The other would perhaps not.`

Bachchan himself features in the movie, by proxy: the young protanogist is obsessed with the actor and in a hilarious early scene stops at nothing to get the autograph of his idol, played by Feroz Abbas Khan.

Slumdog`s opening sequences are largely in Hindi but the film has little in common with conventional Indian cinema, where films are more about escapism than realism. This has also riled the Big B, as Bachchan is universally known in Bollywood, who seems particularly irked by the critical praise that Indian arthouse cinema has attracted over the decades.

`The commercial escapist world of Indian cinema had vociferously battled for years, on the attention paid and the adulation given to the legendary Satyajit Ray at all the prestigious film festivals of the west, and not a word of appreciation for the entertaining mass oriented box-office blockbusters that were being churned out from Mumbai. The argument: Ray portrayed reality the other, escapism, fantasy and incredulous posturing. Unimpressive for Cannes and Berlin and Venice.`

There may be another reason for Bachchan`s words: he was the original host of the Indian version of Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?, a show that resurrected his career. However, rival Bollywood star Anil Kapoor steals his thunder with a remarkable performance as the creepy host of the game show in Slumdog.

But many fans have rushed to the defence of Boyle`s movie. `Slumdog doesn`t show a complete picture of India or Indians, but few movies show a complete picture of any place or people, particularly a sprawling, expressive, multicultural city like Mumbai. You see a mere slice. Slumdog shows poverty, and it shows wealth, and it shows someone who survives one and is unconcerned with the other. What he is concerned with is LOVE. And that is so Indian,` wrote svhayter on Bachchan`s blog.

Source(s)
Guardian UK

 Post a reply to this

 E-mail this to a friend




Revy
Senior Member

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 15104
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 01:08:20 GMT  Report for Abuse  
While I don't agree with all his opinon here, I do strongly agree with this:

Bachchan added that an Indian director making a western-style film might not meet with the attention lavished on Slumdog Millionaire: 'It's just that the SM idea, authored by an Indian and conceived and cinematically put together by a westerner, gets creative globe recognition. The other would perhaps not.'


I think it is very true, not to put down SM, there have been many other Indian films of that calibre, but if there is no white man touching it they are not recognized.

(an aside for GG, this is another reason I detest the left, the so called compasionate and so caring left are for the most part the most blatant racists you will find any where)

Edited By - Revy - 15 Jan 2009 01:09:00 GMT
Nacholibre
Senior Member

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 4102
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 01:18:03 GMT  Report for Abuse  
No ppl of any country would like to see their own country being portrayed poorly in the eyes of the world.
Individuals may win awards but a country's pride may get hurt in the endeavour.

This is not to take away what Rahman deserves. He is great, no doubt about that.


Edited By - Nacholibre - 15 Jan 2009 01:19:12 GMT
groovygirl
Senior Member

Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9523
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 01:26:07 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Revs
I do strongly agree

India has potential with great history and culture and story lines, sometimes you do need the touch of westerner to bring out the oscar calibre,

Can't remember top of my head, do you know any movie that has won OScars other than British or American?

gg
Nacholibre
Senior Member

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 4102
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 01:41:24 GMT  Report for Abuse  
o you know any movie that has won OScars other than British or American?


A french film won once. It depicts a story of a French father and his little son, the father tries his best to safeguard his little son from the world war. Ultimately, the father hides his son in a large roadside post box but gets killed himself before the war is over. Son survives.

sad story line. I forget the name of the movie or the award..

Edited By - Nacholibre - 15 Jan 2009 01:42:32 GMT
RealKaruna
Senior Member

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 1507
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 01:52:00 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Revy,

I hope to watch the film in the next few days. I'll let you know what I think.

RK
Sritharan
Senior Member

Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 5331
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 01:54:27 GMT  Report for Abuse  
I have not read the Q and A novel. But, I guess the movie must be the faithful adaptation of the novel, which was written by an Indian. Everything has shown in the movie exists in India.

(1) Millions and millions of slum people have been living in less than $1 income per day.

(2) There is an organized crime phenomena called 'mafia beggars', who kidnap kids at the tender age and torture / break arm or leg / remove eyes to create a pity for street begging.

I don't know why Mr. Big 'B' should get angry. Because, many Indian movies depicted the actual poverty and crime world of India. But, those movies only have been watched by Indians.

But SM will reach most of average Westerners' living room. Amitabh fears Westerners will get wrong impression about the country.

But, truth is truth! It is a beautiful film Mr. Amithabh!

Go and dance with a 20-years-old-girl!

Dress in Armani suit and wear expensive western sunglass, Dance around the tree!
Revy
Senior Member

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 15104
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 02:27:03 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Because, many Indian movies depicted the actual poverty and crime world of India.


Yeah these are the parts I do not agree with Big B, the movie was true to life concerning some aspects of India, maybe he has been so long away from those types of areas in India he thinks they no longer exist...

sometimes you do need the touch of westerner to bring out the oscar calibre,


True also, perfect example is the lack of silly dance routines in the middle of the plot for SM (only one at the end :) ) But I still think there are good Indian movies of this caliber that also should be recognized, but I guess dialog being mostly english also helps SM a lot.
groovygirl
Senior Member

Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 9523
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 03:12:47 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Nacho
Sounds like an interesting movie, lemme know if you find the name of it.

Revs
Take movie Gandhi by Richard Attenborough for example!
I could be wrong, has any indian attempted to make a movie of his life? other than the documentaries. Oscar loves touchy stories!
there are good Indian movies

True again, it's all how they promote, I think most foreign movies get picked up by Sundance, Cannes and Tribeca film festivals, Depends on the popularity they probably show in the US or Europe, me thinks.

I am happy for AR, he is the front runner for Oscar, next is Screen Actors Guild award, be sure to watch Revs :))
CheGuevara
Senior Member

Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 2165
Member Profile
LK Information  15 Jan 2009 06:26:58 GMT  Report for Abuse  
Nacho

the name of the movie starts with BEAUTIFUL.....
samadi
Senior Member

Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 5801
Member Profile
LK Information  16 Jan 2009 22:19:00 GMT  Report for Abuse  
the name of the movie starts with BEAUTIFUL.....


Life is beautiful...:):))

thats the name of the movie...
Page | 1  |
 Post a reply to this      E-mail this to a friend



(C) 2000-2008 www.lankanewspapers.com - Sri Lankan News & Discussions - Contact Us - RSS Feed - News Archives - src - FAQ